Case open
Death at the Gilded Lily beat somebody today.
They ran out of questions before they ran out of suspects. The case is still open, and the contradiction is still provably in there.

Noir · 1925, a basement speakeasy on Chicago's South Side
Death at the Gilded Lily
Chicago, 1925. The Gilded Lily's owner is dead behind his own bar — poisoned during the midnight show, while the band played on.
3 suspects · easy · 25–40 min · free
Nothing on this page gives anything away — it knows whether the case was closed and nothing about how.